Question

九．書面表達（滿分15分）

你們班組織全班同學以“ Should we give money to beggars?” 為題，開了一個討論會.

請根據下面表格的提示寫一篇短文，介紹討論情況.

一些同學認為 應該給 1 大部分乞丐都是假裝的; 2.乞討是他們賺錢的便利途徑; 3 會助長懶惰;

孤寡老人不能自食其力而乞討； 有些學生因家境貧困，付不起學費而乞討; 有些殘疾人也只能以乞討為生; 你自己的觀點…

注意：1. 文章的開頭已給出另一些學生認為 不應該給

2. 詞數120 左右 （ 不計已給的開頭語）

3  參考詞匯: inferior group 弱勢群體

 We have had a heated debate today on whether we should give money to beggars and we have different opinions…

Answer 1

 We have had a heated debate today on whether we should give money to beggars and

we have different opinions.

Some believe that we should give money to beggars because some of them are old people who can’t live on their own. Among them are also students who have dropped out of school because their families are so poor. And we also see some disabled people. So we should give money to those who need our help.

    On the other hand, however, many more students think we shouldn’t give them money because most of the beggars want to make money more easily. They are not real beggars. Besides, to give money encourages them to be lazy even if they have the ability to work.

As far as I’m concerned, we should help the people of inferior group, but when we give money , we should be careful.